Rabbi Anita Steiner[Rabbi Anita Steiner is an RRC graduate and a long-time resident of Ashkelon. She is the chair of Rabbis for Human Rights. This story was written around 5 P.M. today Israel time. Ed.] On the radio, every hour and also on the half hour, the names of the soldiers who have died are listed as well as the times and places of their funerals. The Israeli casualties are mounting, in addition to all the casualties in Gaza.
Yesterday after the seventh rocket here, I stopped counting. The house of some one I know was damaged by a rocket that was close to hers. Even when there aren't rockets landing, there is a lot of noise. Helicopters, planes, jets, artillery being fired, and many unknown booms. And so many of our kids, brothers, husbands, friends, either in Gaza or poised to go in.
One friend, is volunteering at the "emergency war room" at the city hall. He said it is amazing the sophisticated equipment there. There is a huge screen, that projects a picture of the entire city ( we're around 120,000 people living here) apparentely from a satellite that shows immediately where rockets have landed. The computerized system also shows if there are handicapped people, people who are bedridden, etc., in the area who might need special help. So in addition to the firefighters, MDA - Magen David Adom, bulldozers and others that go to a site right away - social workers and others go too.
The same friend was taking a train to Tel Aviv yesterday, and there was a siren. The train stopped and everyone was instructed to lie down on the floor and cover thier heads with their hands and arms. Not too sophisticated, but what else can be done?
A friend's teenage daughter was on a bus when there was a siren. Of course the bus stopped and all the doors were opened. But she could not get out because she was sitting next to an elderly woman with a bunch of bags from shopping at the shuk all around her, and the older woman could not move. The teenager was terrified, because there was no way she could even climb over the woman if the bus was hit.
There are "quiet" frequencies on the radio, that tell you when there are sirens, I rember them from the first Gulf war when there were Scuds. You can use it at night, keeping the volume way up high to make sure you hear a siren, for people who are shomrei shabbat, if the warning sriens aren't strong enough where you live, etc. They were set up that each region would have its own frequency. But unfortunately there are now so many areas in range of the rockets fired from Gaza, that several towns, cities, and regional councils are on the same frequency.
My friend and tennis partner tried to call her friend in the north of Gaza. Her friend is a building contractor, and built her miklat- the bomb shelter and an addition to the house. (I wrote about this when the rockets started in Ashkelon in March). Her friend's name is Jihad, yes that is his name. But none of his phones were working. She was hoping that he had built himself a miklat, as he is head of a family of 30 people.
People have interesting stories about their current showering habits. One person said she wasn't going to shower while the rockets continued to be fired. She said that if she were to die in the shower, she didn't want everyone to see pictures of her nude!
Another friend says that she doesn't shower often, as they have to go down two floors to get to a safe place. They live on the top floor of an apartment house and their apartment faced south. First she washes her hair in the sink, dressed, then in the shower she washes one partof her body, rinses, and does another part. They have a big terry robe next to the shower. Her daughter found another solution - she wears her bikini when showering.
One person I know won't make omelettes any more. One day she had started to make one, and there was a siren. She had to turn off the gas before rushing to safely. When she returned to the kitchen she had to beat the eggs again and started to add spices, another siren, and then another. In all it took her 30 minutes to finish the omelette.
And I heard of someone only eating salads and sandwiches, as she is afraid to use the gas.
Everyone seems to have their own worries and quirks regarding the rockets.But everyone, when they go out thinks:
May there be an end to this violence. May there be a ceasefire. May the world be concerned with what is happening on both sides of this border.
Comments
Comparing problems
All the concern about Gazans doesn't change that they elected a government with a charter to kill Jews & annihilate Israel, then supported that government without protest to change that charter.
In wartime, the USSR citizens, Germans, Japanese, all suffered horribly. However, actions are measured on their need. Those that declare war actively by firing rockets daily for years, bear full responsibility for the horrors of war they've declared.
I feel for the Gazans' but I wonder what motivates people not to understand Hamas's goals & actions. Or to treat Arabs in such a bigoted way that they are not held responsible for their own choices as though they are animals or uncivilized & can't know otherwise.
I wonder too about someone who can feel for the suffering of others but has trouble doing it for Jews. I wonder if it has to do with Europe, & the teachings of others that we shouldn't stand up for ourselves & we should absorb the comments thrown at us.
Actually, I can understand how someone can go where this writer did. The media is limited & lopsided (sometimes bias against both views at the same time.) The left has data it got from radical right wing Arabs who don't want peace, then white washed so much you woul'd never guess the source was so bias against Jews or Israel unless you took a moment to think about it. Or as I did, a couple years to research.
I was in Sderot in the spring. It tenses to be hard to understand what day in & day out pressure of being bombed at is like. It does compare to what the Gazans are experiencing. For them it's 16 days. For Sderot it's 8 years every single moment of every day. This year alone it's been 3000 missiles. Israel has less casualties because she has bomb shelters on every corner. Hamas didn't build a single shelter for her people. We all know Hamas uses her people as cover for shooting. Then there's that media bias. It just reported how many Palestinians were killed as one lump sum, but for Israel it differentiated soldiers vs. civilians killed. This was Fox news, so if they are pro-israel bias, it really makes you wonder what's so hard about being more neutral in reporting. Why is it so easy to report negatively about Israel? It has to do with a lot more than policy when such a simple count can not be reported neutrally.
So there are some more thoughts on the topic. This video of Hamas members speaking about their goals impresses on me that they aren't just about some political concerns:
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=umlWYGLixPc&feature=related
First Person Account
Catherine,
Rabbi Steiner's post is a first-person account of her own experience. She doesn't compare the challenges she faces with those in Gaza or anyone else. She is simply telling her story.
I see a split among liberally minded Jews about the rightness or wrongness of Israel's actions in Gaza now. I think Rabbi Steiner's piece at least gives us a common text that we can share and so therefore be "together" in some aspects even as we disagree.
I understand you may have come to the JRF web site looking for material or official responses or approaches etc... in response to the current situation and you only found Rabbi Steiner's article. Her piece should not have to bare the weight of the desire for leadership and thoughtfulness at this difficult time.
I'm glad you posted and I hope others do as well.
Shai
First-person reflection? perspective?
Shai,
Thanks for your email. Rabbi Steiner made a choice about what to write, and the jrf.org editorial staff choose what to publish. Where is the prophetic voice in modern Jewish life? Perhaps only Gideon Levy's in HaAretz and not in the rabbinate?
I quote from your Darfur page:
Shai and Anita: where do you see "leadership and thoughtfulness" that meets the challenge of the last two weeks? I can find it only in the press and political activism. And where is that reconstructionist existentialism that engages with the secular world and builds a meaningful Jewish life within it?
The bikini in the shower and the 30-minute omelette are idle curiosities. Do you have more to say?
Catherine
Shalom Rav
Catherine,
Check out Rabbi Brant Rosen's block at: http://rabbibrant.com
Shai
washing and cooking habits under fire
Dear Rabbi Steiner,
As chair of Rabbis for Human Rights, what relation do you see between Israelis who make special arrangements to shower and prepare food, and listen out for sirens, and Gazans who have no running water or electricity, queue for 5 hours for food rations, and cower in basements listening to explosions?
I don't doubt that living in Ashkelon under rocket fire is frightening. You, better than me, can perhaps imagine then all the more what it is like to be a Palestinian. You better, than most of us, are in position to call for human rights for the people in Gaza; and if not now, when?
Catherine Lyons
(formerly a member of a reconstructionist congregation, and now a member of a UK liberal congregation)